Is there anything that can be done to make the team competition fairer, or at least give it some point? In much the same way as Sky run their team comps on colours, and a random draw? We have 3 teams with twice the entrants of the others, and some teams with 1 or 2 players playing each week. Teams limited to 5 or 6 players per team, Top 3 only to count would make the team competition much more viable. We could have 20 teams per week, or 10 teams (depending upon numbers). You stay in a team for a full month cycle, and not playing is letting your side down (maybe have a substitute system) I know people enjoy their current teams, but the team competition of DTD is, frankly, a farce. If people really want to stay in current teams, then maybe split your teams in to A B C D E etc - can rank your players on previous performance and have a promotion / relegation system within the teams for a bit of extra light-hearted rivalry. If I am lone voice, then tell me so, and I will plod on. Posted by Eyeman
....Diamond Won Team Game this week with just ONE entry!!!!
It has been looked at in past, Regular playing Captains felt it best left as its been for nearly 3 Years!
To help, I split My HitSquad into 2 Distinct Teams each Month, again made fairer!
I will post up the Full results over time, latley you will see it has become more open!!
The Individual DTD League Works, run by DTW The Team DTD League Works, run by HitManRV ME!!
They have always complimented each other, we throw alot of our time into keeping them running, aided respectivly by admins in each League from across all Teams, Dave Boxter, Poker Trev, Alan Maxally, Teresa betterha1f,
.....Sky Donate some prizes, but The Community Started, Supported & Run Both Leagues!
Other Options have started succesfully, like the Orfordable on friday ably run by Trev & Dave!
.....Anyone can Start their Own idea....WE STARTED OURS!!!
Good to see you back playing Graham, we missed you, TKP getting a few in again Nice One... BUT ITS BEEN WORKING FINE TA!!!! lol!!
The thing is, Dave. originally the teams were all small and similar in size. If you think it's fair to have 1 team with 20 entrants, and one team with one entrant, then we're never going to reach a solution.
The team competition no longer works. If you want to make it fair, and a true team competition, then teams have to be of equal size (as much as possible). You don't see the Tour de France with 100 riders from 1 team and 3 or 4 from another. There's a reason for that. If you just want THS, TPT or Hit Jams to win it every time, then your scheme works wonderfully. Divide the big teams into workable sizes each month, and the team competition might become meaningful. As it is, it's a guaranteed freeroll for the big teams. Have fun with that!
Your argument that this week's team comp was won by a solo player is actually an argument against the status quo. How can a single person win a team competition merely by winning the overall? That's madeness. Each week someone wins the overall. If, by chance, the reamaining places are divided up between the other teams right, that individual can win the team event? I have never heard anything so ludicrous.
Just because something has worked in the past, does not mean it will continue to do so.
P.S. Your last sentence does you no credit. If it wourked just fine, ta. I wouldn't be making these observations.
Just asking for open debate. If I am in the huge monority, I will gladly accept that.
The thing is, Dave. originally the teams were all small and similar in size. If you think it's fair to have 1 team with 20 entrants, and one team with one entrant, then we're never going to reacha solution. The team competition no longer works. If you want to make it fair, and a true team competition, then teams have to be of equal size (as much as possible). You don't see the Tour de France with 100 riders from 1 team and 3 or 4 from another. There's a reason for that. If you just want THS, TPT or Hit Jams to win it every time, then your scheme works wonderfully. Divide the big teams into workable sizes each month, and the team competition might become meaningful. As it is, it's a guaranteed freeroll for the big teams. Have fun with that! Your argument that this weeks team comp was won by a solo player is actually an argument against the status quo. How can a single person win a team competition merely by winning the overall? That's madeness. Each week someone wins the overall. If, bu chance, the reamaining places are divided up between the other teams right, that individual can win the team event? I have never heard anything so ludicrous. Just because something has worked in the past, does not mean it will ocntinue to do so. Posted by Eyeman
pmsl!!! so dont play Team League mate, enter as IND!!!
if honest, we aint seen you much this last year, No Other Captains or regulars have complained !!
....its fluidity is its Success!! Did we not have this Debate in June 2011, pmsl!!
.....Anyway, it aint changing, lol!
It takes 4 hours of my time Mon Nite, 2 hours Tuesday Day, Many others Contribute to both Leagues Success, we certainly are not going to make it more difficult for ourselves, when all involved agreed to formats & tweeks in past!
Champions Runners-up May '11 Team Knightplop Team HitSquad June '11 Team PokerTrev Team HitSquad July '11 Team 51Team PokerTrev Aug.'11 Team PokerTrevTeam 51 Sept.'11 Team 51Team HitSquad Oct. '11 Team HitSquad Team 51 Nov.'11 Team PokerTrevTeam Hitsquad Dec.'11 Team HitSquad Team PokerTrev Jan.'12 Team PokerTrev Team 51 Feb.'12 DYM LegEndsTeam Hitsquad March12 Team HitSquadTeam PokerTrev April '12 Team HitSquad Team PokerTrev May 12 PokerTitans Team Hitsquad June 12 Team HitSquad PokerTitans July 12 Team 51Team HitSquad Aug 12 Team HitSquad Team 51 Sept 12 Team 51 Team HitSquad Oct 12 Team HitSquad Team Diamond Nov 12 Team Diamond Team HitSquad Dec 12 Team HitSquad Team Diamond Jan 13 Team HitSquadTeam 51 Feb 13 Team HitSquad Team Diamond March13 Team HitSquad Poker Titans April 13 Team HitSquad Poker Titans May 13 HitSquad Jams Team Diamond June13 Team 51 HitSquad Jams July 13 HitSquad Jams Team 51 Aug.13 HitSquad JamsPoker Titans Sept 13HitSquad JamsHitSquad Donks Oct 13 Poker Titans HitSquad Donks Nov 13 HitSquad Donks HitSquad Jams Dec 13 Poker Titans HitSquad Jams Jan 14 HitSquad Jams HitSquad Donks
OK. Debate over. Everyone who wants to have a say has spoken, I am in a minority of 1.
I will continue to play, and as a member of TKP. I have played practically every week for the last 2½ years, with a 6 month self-exclusion from poker when I was having personal problems last year.
As an aside, if anyone does want to offer opinions on the current team part of DTD, I assume Dave will allow you to reply on this thread. I see it will do no good, but a little free speech never hurt.
Sry if I sounded Sharp Graham, but i have business to run here, like you!
We put this time in During Day to keep people informed of results, when we can grab a moment to help Community!
It Not easy to respond to Critisism on our Working Threads, articulatley, responsibly sometimes in open forum if Critiqued, please do pm me, or Mesaage me in friends of Sky Poker FB Group, as this type of debate here normally only attracts others who wish to stir a hornets nest as in past!!
It is Good to talk you are Correct!!
Back to Work for Me!!
Ps Thanks for the Many thanks from Everyone to The DTD Admins!! ...it really makes it all worthwhile...!!
STOP!!!!! Am kidding, we regularly get thanked & appreciated!
Is there anything that can be done to make the team competition fairer, or at least give it some point? In much the same way as Sky run their team comps on colours, and a random draw? We have 3 teams with twice the entrants of the others, and some teams with 1 or 2 players playing each week. Teams limited to 5 or 6 players per team, Top 3 only to count would make the team competition much more viable. We could have 20 teams per week, or 10 teams (depending upon numbers). You stay in a team for a full month cycle, and not playing is letting your side down (maybe have a substitute system) I know people enjoy their current teams, but the team competition of DTD is, frankly, a farce. If people really want to stay in current teams, then maybe split your teams in to A B C D E etc - can rank your players on previous performance and have a promotion / relegation system within the teams for a bit of extra light-hearted rivalry. If I am lone voice, then tell me so, and I will plod on. Posted by Eyeman
Sorry but i feel that using the word 'farce' is being disrespectful to the effort and organisation that people put in to, not only putting on the DTD but, promoting players to play in them. THS have split their team, however, i can say that a lot is done to promote a good team 'atmosphere'. Surely its a matter of other teams getting more members and promoting good poker rather than diluting it with teams of five. A team of one won it this week though i'm sure that team has more members and could have provided more on the night. Lets not decry the effort made by individuals to represent their teams and promote playing. Lets raise the participation rather than dilute it. DTD has introduced prizes for individual perforfomances over the week and month. Its not for the organisers to sort out and calling it a farce is wrong imo. Maybe starting your own one may show you the difficulties involved. Good luck sir!
Myself along with many others really appreciate all the effort you and the other admins put in to this and im sure it takes you hours on end, I have only been part of this for a short time but love it and cant wait to get home from work on a monday and play dtd games it so much different to any other nite and also my favorite one of the week.. I normally cant wait till the following monday to do it all over again as it is run so well, keep up the great work u do a fantasic job thanks again...
I firmly beleive this is a fanastic tournment were everyon is involved, i think that if any alteration where need to teams it would be very unfair on all the hard work the team captains have made to build there team up, and if you in a team with small numbers no harm in doing a massive recruitment driver putting posts out there as many players play the dtd that are not involved in any teams at the moment its just a case of finding them and chatting to them in chat window or be message.
I for one love the DTD mondays i always play when i am not working on monday nights, first class competition and run very well indeed.
well played to all involved again another great sucess
Sounds like one of our golf weekends, you'll always have the moaners. If it ain't broke don't fix it..... format seems to be spot on, it's up to us indies to group up n maybe cap how many to a team. I'm more than happy to join a team or start one. Look forward to next Monday, it's events like this that keeps me at sites. So keep up the good work Hitman n i'll see you on the tables. Thxs stanford07.
I firmly beleive this is a fanastic tournment were everyon is involved, i think that if any alteration where need to teams it would be very unfair onall the hard work the team captains have made to build there team up, and if you in a team with small numbers no harm in doing a massive recruitment driver putting posts out there as many players play the dtd that are not involved in any teams at the moment its just a case of finding them and chatting to them in chat window or be message. I for one love the DTD mondays i always play when i am not working on monday nights, first class competition and run very well indeed. well played to all involved again another great sucess Posted by haylez83
So basically, if you have attracted (lets not kid ourselves - "said yes to") more members, you deserve an advantage, and to hell with fairness?
Look, I am not a moaner, and this discussion is taking place elsewhere in a considered manner.
DTD is an individual event. I love it. I play it whenever I can. The team aspect adds a little fun, but when one team has 20 regulalr runners and another team has one runner, it obviously isn't functioning as a team event. When a single runner can win the team event, it becomes plain wrong.
I was just suggesting alternatives to the team side of the event to add fairness.
The problem is historical, and probably can't be resolved. Back in the day, a limit should have been put on number of people in each team. After "X" members, you form / join a new team. IIf nevessary that team could be Hit Squad 2. TKP2 etc. However, we can't uninvent the wheel, so we have what we have and have to try and make the best of it.
As an aside, I appreciate the hard work that goes into the event each week. I really do.
In Response to Re: FORUM DTD Monday 27th Jan. 2014 - Open To All Individuals With Prizes For Weekly & Monthly Top 3 Good Luck All : So basically, if you have attracted (lets not kid ourselves - "said yes to") more members, you deserve an advantage, and to hell with fairness? Look, I am not a moaner, and this discussion is taking place elsewhere in a considered manner. DTD is an individual event. I love it. I play it whenever I can. The team aspect adds a little fun, but when one team has 20 regulalr runners and another team has one runner, it obviously isn't functioning as a team event. When a single runner can win the team event, it becomes plain wrong. I was just suggesting alternatives to the team side of the event to add fairness. As an aside, I appreciate the hard work that goes into the event each week. I really do. Posted by Eyeman
Hi Eyman. Firstly......It's great to see you getting involved and making suggestions with a view to improve things, so thank you for your input.
I am a little tied up, but would be happy to discuss this in greater length and hopefully also get some possitive input from other players too.
If you can give me a little more time to respond a little later, then hopefully we can open up a positive discussion for all.
Yes, THS and TPT have had a more open recruitment policy, and have built there teams this way (incidentally this is no longer true of THS as we have realised the need to control numbers a little). To suggest that these teams success has come purely through strength of number is frankly a little insulting. I can only speak for HitSquad but I'm sure the same is true of TPT, but there has been an awful lot of work put in by a lot of people to grow the team and to improve our players. This is clearly evident on our results outside of DTD and indeed outside of Sky Poker.
Eyeman, I accept you have valid concerns over the structure of the team element of the DTD competition but to blame this on other peoples pro activity and hard work is just wrong in my opinion. There is literally nothing stopping any other team doing exactly what THS and TPT have done if they choose to.
In Response to Re: FORUM DTD Monday 27th Jan. 2014 - Open To All Individuals With Prizes For Weekly & Monthly Top 3 Good Luck All : So basically, if you have attracted (lets not kid ourselves - "said yes to") more members, you deserve an advantage, and to hell with fairness? Look, I am not a moaner, and this discussion is taking place elsewhere in a considered manner. DTD is an individual event. I love it. I play it whenever I can. The team aspect adds a little fun, but when one team has 20 regulalr runners and another team has one runner, it obviously isn't functioning as a team event. When a single runner can win the team event, it becomes plain wrong. I was just suggesting alternatives to the team side of the event to add fairness. The problem is historical, and probably can't be resolved. Back in the day, a limit should have been put on number of people in each team. After "X" members, you form / join a new team. If nevessary that team could be Hit Squad 2. TKP2 etc. However, we can't uninvent the wheel, so we have what we have and have to try and make the best of it. As an aside, I appreciate the hard work that goes into the event each week. I really do. Posted by Eyeman
Graham I see your point about team balance but maybe if other teams put in the same effort as TPT and Hitsquad do then maybe we would have a more balanced competition. Yes we do get some players just making one post saying can I join your team and we never hear of them again but the majority of our recruits come from playing other TPT members at the tables. I have had many players asking me what TPT is and what are the advantages of joining a team (not just TPT I mean any team). Final tables especially surprise some opponents when they see the TPT rail and wonder whats going on. That is the major way that we get recruits to the team. We have seen our numbers swell rapidly over the last 6 months but that is the nature of the beast as our numbers increase then so does the publicity for the team. Bear in mind also that although our member list now stands at 107 by my reckoning at least 40 of those are not currently active on Sky Poker. With regards to the DTD we do not recruit solely for DTD players although that is welcome and considering the size of the team our DTD turnout is quite modest. It is only recently that we have broken the 20 barrier and this week we were down to 15. Surely it wouldn't take too much effort for some of the other teams to catch up if they want to, and I can tell you that is not the case with all teams.
I didn't really want to wade in and post an opinion on this, because I usually keep my mouth shut
...but I'm on my lunch break, so figured I'd chuck in my thoughts.
Yes, it would make perfect sense for all teams to have the same number of participants. Eleven players on a football team; five players on a basketball team; fifteen players in a rugby squad. You don't have an imbalance there because, well... as you have alluded to - correctly, to some degree - it just isn't fair, is it?
And if this was a serious contest, I would agree. One hundred percent. Each team would be capped at (for instance) thirty members; rules would be set; penalties would be implemented for missing games; etc, etc.
But - for me at least - DTD, and more broadly, the function of each team, has never been about that. I'm a relatively new member of The HitSquad. Did I join because I thought they were the best team on Sky, with the biggest clout? No (sorry Dave!). Did I join because I thought they could help advance my game further than any other? No again. I joined because there was a core group of guys and girls that seemed to enjoy their games, and I thought it would be good to get to know a few of these people a little better. Forum friendship, if you like.
It would be relatively simple to implement a more rigid form of team-based competition, but the problem you will have is that - and somebody correct me if I'm speaking out of turn here - most forum regulars on Sky would rather a relaxed, no-strings, form of contest than a regimented league/ladder format, as you have alluded to. There are plenty of tournaments on every evening that takes care of serious competition.
This is just a bit of fun on the side, and we all like some of that
I didn't really want to wade in and post an opinion on this, because I usually keep my mouth shut ...but I'm on my lunch break, so figured I'd chuck in my thoughts. Yes, it would make perfect sense for all teams to have the same number of participants. Eleven players on a football team; five players on a basketball team; fifteen players in a rugby squad. You don't have an imbalance there because, well... as you have alluded to - correctly, to some degree - it just isn't fair, is it? And if this was a serious contest, I would agree. One hundred percent. Each team would be capped at (for instance) thirty members; rules would be set; penalties would be implemented for missing games; etc, etc. But - for me at least - DTD, and more broadly, the function of each team, has never been about that. I'm a relatively new member of The HitSquad. Did I join because I thought they were the best team on Sky, with the biggest clout? No (sorry Dave!). Did I join because I thought they could help advance my game further than any other? No again. I joined because there was a core group of guys and girls that seemed to enjoy their games, and I thought it would be good to get to know a few of these people a little better. Forum friendship, if you like. It would be relatively simple to implement a more rigid form of team-based competition, but the problem you will have is that - and somebody correct me if I'm speaking out of turn here - most forum regulars on Sky would rather a relaxed, no-strings, form of contest than a regimented league/ladder format, as you have alluded to. There are plenty of tournaments on every evening that takes care of serious competition. This is just a bit of fun on the side, and we all like some of that Posted by Slipwater
Excellent, well-reasoned post. I think I (and everyone) have come to the conclusion that, as you say, the team competition aspect is a bit of fun, and shouldn't be taken seriously.
In Response to Re: FORUM DTD Monday 27th Jan. 2014 - Winner was EVILPINGU (DIA) who had a score of 13 pts (made 1x FT) & Wins Entry to Mondays £33 BH GL in that : Excellent, well-reasoned post. I think I (and everyone) have come to the conclusion that, as you say, the team competition aspect is a bit of fun, and shouldn't be taken seriously. Posted by Eyeman
I didn't really want to wade in and post an opinion on this, because I usually keep my mouth shut ...but I'm on my lunch break, so figured I'd chuck in my thoughts. Yes, it would make perfect sense for all teams to have the same number of participants. Eleven players on a football team; five players on a basketball team; fifteen players in a rugby squad. You don't have an imbalance there because, well... as you have alluded to - correctly, to some degree - it just isn't fair, is it? And if this was a serious contest, I would agree. One hundred percent. Each team would be capped at (for instance) thirty members; rules would be set; penalties would be implemented for missing games; etc, etc. But - for me at least - DTD, and more broadly, the function of each team, has never been about that. I'm a relatively new member of The HitSquad. Did I join because I thought they were the best team on Sky, with the biggest clout? No (sorry Dave!). Did I join because I thought they could help advance my game further than any other? No again. I joined because there was a core group of guys and girls that seemed to enjoy their games, and I thought it would be good to get to know a few of these people a little better. Forum friendship, if you like. It would be relatively simple to implement a more rigid form of team-based competition, but the problem you will have is that - and somebody correct me if I'm speaking out of turn here - most forum regulars on Sky would rather a relaxed, no-strings, form of contest than a regimented league/ladder format, as you have alluded to. There are plenty of tournaments on every evening that takes care of serious competition. This is just a bit of fun on the side, and we all like some of that Posted by Slipwater
Excellent Post Brian Thank You!!!!!!!
Highlited is ONE OF MAIN REASON's I hope People Join!!
Rest is just sublime!! I may have to make you My HitSquad Team Diplomat, as I have a coarser Tongue, that is sometimes misread!!
Thanks also to Eyeman for taking time to consider others opinion, as I do try to myself!!
In Response to Re: FORUM DTD Monday 27th Jan. 2014 - Winner was EVILPINGU (DIA) who had a score of 13 pts (made 1x FT) & Wins Entry to Mondays £33 BH GL in that : Excellent, well-reasoned post. I think I (and everyone) have come to the conclusion that, as you say, the team competition aspect is a bit of fun, and shouldn't be taken seriously. Posted by Eyeman
In Response to Re: FORUM DTD Monday 27th Jan. 2014 - Winner was EVILPINGU (DIA) who had a score of 13 pts (made 1x FT) & Wins Entry to Mondays £33 BH GL in that : You aren't sure? Posted by Slipwater
At this late hour things can get a bit blurry! & I like to be polite ;-)
Comments
....Diamond Won Team Game this week with just ONE entry!!!!
It has been looked at in past, Regular playing Captains felt it best left as its been for nearly 3 Years!
To help, I split My HitSquad into 2 Distinct Teams each Month, again made fairer!
I will post up the Full results over time, latley you will see it has become more open!!
GL Graham!!
The Team DTD League Works, run by HitManRV ME!!
They have always complimented each other, we throw alot of our time into keeping them running, aided respectivly by admins in each League from across all Teams, Dave Boxter, Poker Trev, Alan Maxally, Teresa betterha1f,
.....Sky Donate some prizes, but The Community Started, Supported & Run Both Leagues!
Other Options have started succesfully, like the Orfordable on friday ably run by Trev & Dave!
.....Anyone can Start their Own idea....WE STARTED OURS!!!
Good to see you back playing Graham, we missed you, TKP getting a few in again Nice One...
BUT ITS BEEN WORKING FINE TA!!!! lol!!
The team competition no longer works. If you want to make it fair, and a true team competition, then teams have to be of equal size (as much as possible). You don't see the Tour de France with 100 riders from 1 team and 3 or 4 from another. There's a reason for that. If you just want THS, TPT or Hit Jams to win it every time, then your scheme works wonderfully. Divide the big teams into workable sizes each month, and the team competition might become meaningful. As it is, it's a guaranteed freeroll for the big teams. Have fun with that!
Your argument that this week's team comp was won by a solo player is actually an argument against the status quo. How can a single person win a team competition merely by winning the overall? That's madeness. Each week someone wins the overall. If, by chance, the reamaining places are divided up between the other teams right, that individual can win the team event? I have never heard anything so ludicrous.
Just because something has worked in the past, does not mean it will continue to do so.
P.S. Your last sentence does you no credit. If it wourked just fine, ta. I wouldn't be making these observations.
Just asking for open debate. If I am in the huge monority, I will gladly accept that.
pmsl!!! so dont play Team League mate, enter as IND!!!
if honest, we aint seen you much this last year, No Other Captains or regulars have complained !!
....its fluidity is its Success!! Did we not have this Debate in June 2011, pmsl!!
.....Anyway, it aint changing, lol!
It takes 4 hours of my time Mon Nite, 2 hours Tuesday Day, Many others Contribute to both Leagues Success, we certainly are not going to make it more difficult for ourselves, when all involved agreed to formats & tweeks in past!
GL Mate!!
Well Done TKP on winning First One!!!
RESULTS FROM START OF FORUM DTD TEAM LEAGUE!!!
{Started by HITMAN_RV May 2011}
Champions Runners-up
May '11 Team Knightplop Team HitSquad
June '11 Team PokerTrev Team HitSquad
July '11 Team 51 Team PokerTrev
Aug.'11 Team PokerTrev Team 51
Sept.'11 Team 51 Team HitSquad
Oct. '11 Team HitSquad Team 51
Nov.'11 Team PokerTrev Team Hitsquad
Dec.'11 Team HitSquad Team PokerTrev
Jan.'12 Team PokerTrev Team 51
Feb.'12 DYM LegEnds Team Hitsquad
March12 Team HitSquad Team PokerTrev
April '12 Team HitSquad Team PokerTrev
May 12 PokerTitans Team Hitsquad
June 12 Team HitSquad PokerTitans
July 12 Team 51 Team HitSquad
Aug 12 Team HitSquad Team 51
Sept 12 Team 51 Team HitSquad
Oct 12 Team HitSquad Team Diamond
Nov 12 Team Diamond Team HitSquad
Dec 12 Team HitSquad Team Diamond
Jan 13 Team HitSquad Team 51
Feb 13 Team HitSquad Team Diamond
March13 Team HitSquad Poker Titans
April 13 Team HitSquad Poker Titans
May 13 HitSquad Jams Team Diamond
June13 Team 51 HitSquad Jams
July 13 HitSquad Jams Team 51
Aug.13 HitSquad Jams Poker Titans
Sept 13 HitSquad Jams HitSquad Donks
Oct 13 Poker Titans HitSquad Donks
Nov 13 HitSquad Donks HitSquad Jams
Dec 13 Poker Titans HitSquad Jams
Jan 14 HitSquad Jams HitSquad Donks
I will continue to play, and as a member of TKP. I have played practically every week for the last 2½ years, with a 6 month self-exclusion from poker when I was having personal problems last year.
As an aside, if anyone does want to offer opinions on the current team part of DTD, I assume Dave will allow you to reply on this thread. I see it will do no good, but a little free speech never hurt.
We put this time in During Day to keep people informed of results, when we can grab a moment to help Community!
It Not easy to respond to Critisism on our Working Threads, articulatley, responsibly sometimes in open forum if Critiqued, please do pm me, or Mesaage me in friends of Sky Poker FB Group, as this type of debate here normally only attracts others who wish to stir a hornets nest as in past!!
It is Good to talk you are Correct!!
Back to Work for Me!!
Ps Thanks for the Many thanks from Everyone to The DTD Admins!!
...it really makes it all worthwhile...!!
STOP!!!!! Am kidding, we regularly get thanked & appreciated!
XxX
GL Mate, hope to have Beer with you soon!
Apology for Tone!!!! LOLOL!
My Wife always says that too!!
If it ain't broke don't fix it..... format seems to be spot on, it's up to us indies
to group up n maybe cap how many to a team. I'm more than happy to join a
team or start one.
Look forward to next Monday, it's events like this that keeps me at sites.
So keep up the good work Hitman n i'll see you on the tables.
Thxs stanford07.
However, we can't uninvent the wheel, so we have what we have and have to try and make the best of it.
Firstly......It's great to see you getting involved and making suggestions with a view to improve things, so thank you for your input.
I am a little tied up, but would be happy to discuss this in greater length and hopefully also get some possitive input from other players too.
If you can give me a little more time to respond a little later, then hopefully we can open up a positive discussion for all.
Thanks
Pokertrev..
Bear in mind also that although our member list now stands at 107 by my reckoning at least 40 of those are not currently active on Sky Poker. With regards to the DTD we do not recruit solely for DTD players although that is welcome and considering the size of the team our DTD turnout is quite modest. It is only recently that we have broken the 20 barrier and this week we were down to 15. Surely it wouldn't take too much effort for some of the other teams to catch up if they want to, and I can tell you that is not the case with all teams.
I didn't really want to wade in and post an opinion on this, because I usually keep my mouth shut

...but I'm on my lunch break, so figured I'd chuck in my thoughts.
Yes, it would make perfect sense for all teams to have the same number of participants. Eleven players on a football team; five players on a basketball team; fifteen players in a rugby squad. You don't have an imbalance there because, well... as you have alluded to - correctly, to some degree - it just isn't fair, is it?
And if this was a serious contest, I would agree. One hundred percent. Each team would be capped at (for instance) thirty members; rules would be set; penalties would be implemented for missing games; etc, etc.
But - for me at least - DTD, and more broadly, the function of each team, has never been about that. I'm a relatively new member of The HitSquad. Did I join because I thought they were the best team on Sky, with the biggest clout? No (sorry Dave!). Did I join because I thought they could help advance my game further than any other? No again. I joined because there was a core group of guys and girls that seemed to enjoy their games, and I thought it would be good to get to know a few of these people a little better. Forum friendship, if you like.
It would be relatively simple to implement a more rigid form of team-based competition, but the problem you will have is that - and somebody correct me if I'm speaking out of turn here - most forum regulars on Sky would rather a relaxed, no-strings, form of contest than a regimented league/ladder format, as you have alluded to. There are plenty of tournaments on every evening that takes care of serious competition.
This is just a bit of fun on the side, and we all like some of that
Excellent Post Brian Thank You!!!!!!!
Highlited is ONE OF MAIN REASON's I hope People Join!!
Rest is just sublime!! I may have to make you My HitSquad Team Diplomat, as I have a coarser Tongue, that is sometimes misread!!
Thanks also to Eyeman for taking time to consider others opinion, as I do try to myself!!
.........and they ALL LIVED HAPPILY EVER AFTER!!!