You need to be logged in to your Sky Poker account above to post discussions and comments.

You might need to refresh your page afterwards.

Sky Poker forums will be temporarily unavailable from 11pm Wednesday July 25th.
Sky Poker Forums is upgrading its look! Stay tuned for the big reveal!

Live Etiquette check/How do you react?

edited May 2011 in The Poker Clinic
I was playing £50 double chance the other night around 65 ppl in 5k starting chips decent structure.  Normally ends up around £4k in pot so its worth cashing in

I have the biggest spew monkey luckbox I know drawn at same table.  He makes a ton of money......once in a blue moon.....which reinforces his horrific play, he forgets he does about £300 a night as standard on the nights I see him.  But that one night where he streaks makes it worthwhile for him.

Anywho he says he's been playing tight lately pffffffff.  First 5 hands he limps in, calls raise after limp.  Breaks even mostly.  Few hands later I find Q's on the button after he limps for 100, I make it 700 as I know he'll come along. 

Hu to flop 1550 in pot I have 4k back.  10J5.  He opens for 1000 I flat.  I'm never folding, he will keep firing just for the chance to show a bluff.

HU ti turn 3550 in pot I have 3k 10J53 He opens for 3k, I say ok and call, but he wont turn his hand over for showdown.  Hand itself is mostly immaterial, just curious as to you guys POV on the etiquette and how you react.

So I turn over my Q's, he keeps his hand in his hand.  Dealer protests, I say just let him be a berk and deal the river.  Dealer deals (a) K

He pulls one card from his holding, flips it over, being a K.  I shake my head.  Villain scoops pot I shout rebuy. 

I say I need to see both cards, as I called and showdown was had.  He point blank refuses.  I want to see what he called 700 then bluffed streets with, also I want to show the table how much of a spewbox he is.

Dealer goes to collect the cards and I say no.  Matched bet is matched bet, I want to see his other card.  This goes on for a bit, for some reason I'm the one getting grief from the rest of the table.  I ask for TD, villain stands up throws his card at me - being a 2. I kind of see red, get a bit verbal, not at card but at actions of spewbox.

Got to feel I'm in the right here?

Comments

  • edited May 2011
    Ye ur right, i wouldn't turn my cards over if he isn't turning his over
  • edited May 2011
    Yeah I agree, or either you or the dealer should have called the TD over before the river was dealt.
  • edited May 2011
    I haven't played much live but I know you have a right to see ANY hand which reaches showdown.  Personally I would never ask to see a losing hand which was mucked unless someone had previously asked to see mine, in which case I would ask to see EVERY hand of the player who asked me thereafter.

    But when you have won the pot I think it's very bad etiquette to think you don't need to show your hand.
  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:
    I haven't played much live but I know you have a right to see ANY hand which reaches showdown.  Personally I would never ask to see a losing hand which was mucked unless someone had previously asked to see mine, in which case I would ask to see EVERY hand of the player who asked me thereafter. But when you have won the pot I think it's very bad etiquette to think you don't need to show your hand.
    Posted by AyrGraeme
    Exactly.  Just so people know, I'm fully aware of the fact he has to show both.  Just wondering how people would react in same spot, after he refuses to show kicker then stands and throws it at you.  I get in his face abit, just wondering if others would have reacted so strongly :p - or if I was perhaps slightly out of line.

    If he misses his 3 outer on river I wouldnt have asked to see his hand, just carry on as normal.
  • edited May 2011
    I dont play live enough to be sure of any of this, so feel free to correct me:

    1. Showdown is not until river, so he is entitled not to show his hand when money goes in
    2. afaik, you have to show 2 cards to claim a pot
    3. You are entitled to see his cards. However it is usually considered bad etiquette to ask to see someones hand if they just want to muck it. I know thats not really the situation here, but it may be why rest of table gave you some grief, although its more likely they are just fools
    4. Throwing a card at you is completely unacceptable, and he should have received some sort of punishment

    If its a double chance, why havent you taken your rebuy already so you cover fish? Also why would you want rest of table to know he is a spewbox?
  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:
    I dont play live enough to be sure of any of this, so feel free to correct me: 1. Showdown is not until river, so he is entitled not to show his hand when money goes in. Am not 100% on this.  Pretty sure if bet is matched its showdown time regardless of street in T  2. afaik, you have to show 2 cards to claim a pot 3. You are entitled to see his cards. However it is usually considered bad etiquette to ask to see someones hand if they just want to muck it. I know thats not really the situation here, but it may be why rest of table gave you some grief, although its more likely they are just fools 4. Throwing a card at you is completely unacceptable, and he should have received some sort of punishment If its a double chance, why havent you taken your rebuy already so you cover fish? In this DC you cant use your solitary rebuy as an initial addon.  Only to be used when going broke, before the beginning of 5th level or addon at at end of 4th level.Also why would you want rest of table to know he is a spewbox?  If this guy rolls up some chips early he'll be an obstacle.  Quite happy for him to stack myself off or another opponent who I can maipulate easier than him.  Plus adds abit of steam into his game.
    Posted by grantorino
    I'd recommend to anyone who loves poker to get out there and play live also.  Your playing with a handicap online.  Get out there and see the msery in peoples eyes when they squirm :p
  • edited May 2011
    for a hand to be won at showdown my understanding is BOTH whole cards must be shown. My understanding of the rules if he refuses to show his other card your Queens win the pot.

    Very bad ettiqute and i hope you stacked him later.
  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:
    I dont play live enough to be sure of any of this, so feel free to correct me: 1. Showdown is not until river, so he is entitled not to show his hand when money goes in 2. afaik, you have to show 2 cards to claim a pot 3. You are entitled to see his cards. However it is usually considered bad etiquette to ask to see someones hand if they just want to muck it. I know thats not really the situation here, but it may be why rest of table gave you some grief, although its more likely they are just fools 4. Throwing a card at you is completely unacceptable, and he should have received some sort of punishment If its a double chance, why havent you taken your rebuy already so you cover fish? Also why would you want rest of table to know he is a spewbox?
    Posted by grantorino
    In a tournament i'm pretty sure you have to show both hole cards as Don said.
  • edited May 2011
    Am not 100% on this.  Pretty sure if bet is matched its showdown time regardless of street in T 

    Have definitely played cash games where money went in pre, but cards were only shown when full hand was dealt out. Might be different in tourneys, and it might be something thats different in different casinos
  • edited May 2011
    Yeah pretty sure it's standard to have to show both hole cards in tournies but in cash you don't have to until river card is dealt.


  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:
    Yeah pretty sure it's standard to have to show both hole cards in tournies but in cash you don't have to until river card is dealt.
    Posted by AcidMan27
    This is correct.

    Like I said though, wasnt about the ruling.  Was about the bad etiquette.  Just a really douchey thing to do.

    Some people are like schools in August.                          (No class)
  • edited May 2011
    I'm very surprised that the dealer went ahead and dealt a river without the cards beind exposed.
  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:




    This thread is exactly the type of thing many-online only players like myself find so absorbing and helpful for the day when or if, we decide to give live games a go.

    I'm going to ask Tikay, if the presenters and analyists could start up a blog or discuss this on tv.
  • edited May 2011
    I dont really understand how people jump right in to online poker.  I only play it as a result of playing Live for so many years.  In many ways it seems to be the opposite now though.  Many of he top breakthrough players developing their game online.

    I couldnt really imaginge developing a skillset online then taking it to a live game.  Nor can I imagine just playing online blind, without honing my game live first.  Takes all sorts though :)

    Hard to weigh up the pro's and cons of each
  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:
    I dont really understand how people jump right in to online poker.  I only play it as a result of playing Live for so many years.  In many ways it seems to be the opposite now though.  Many of he top breakthrough players developing their game online. I couldnt really imaginge developing a skillset online then taking it to a live game.  Nor can I imagine just playing online blind, without honing my game live first.  Takes all sorts though :) Hard to weigh up the pro's and cons of each
    Posted by AMYBR
    In my case, I liked to watch poker on tv esp. Sky Poker bcoz it gave you a good grounding of the game.
    I then went and signed up on here and played purely for the social aspect ie: I soon realised I didn't have the BR nor the understanding of BR management to make inroads and carving out serious profit out of the game nor the inclination to spend the time in trying to do so.
    I also, could never have envisaged to go and play live (on my own) in a casino etc. as I was and still am, really clueless about the whole environment.
    A lot of my concerns about entering a 'live-arena' aren't applicable to online play and hence the attraction to play poker is not diminished in any shape or form (bcoz I don't know any different) but I am fully aware by the comments posted on this forum and the SPT blogs....that live play is so much more enjoyable. 

         
  • edited May 2011
    It really truly is.

    I hadnt really considored that going on your own can be so intimidating/concerning.  But casting my mind back it does feel a bit weird the first few times.

    Its very rare you'll meet an utter tool at the table.  Most of my friend + ppl I associate with are poker players.

    For the most part live players are either friendly or very reserved, both serving a purpose.  Its pretty rare to find someone who is an utter jerk for the sake of being a jerk. 

    Most players are very happy to accomadate a newer player, but there are huge early lessons to be learnt and mistakes to be avoided that youre probably unaware of.

    Friend of mine got crushed other weekend as his intention was to raise to £5 @ 50p/1, but didnt verbally announce it, just put a £5 chip in.  Which is a call in most live games.  However if he had put in 5 single £1 chips it is a raise without the verbal, but you cant one chip raise in the majority of casino games (without confirming your intent verbally prior to chip crossing line).  But if you hadnt played, you wouldnt know this.  Lots of pitfalls like this.
  • edited May 2011
    Did this guy get away with throwing cards at you? I wouldnt be too impressed with TD if that is the case

    The other players must be pretty bad if you prefer them to have chips than spewy fish
  • edited May 2011
    I think the strength of my reaction mostly undid my cause :p

    Both just let it go in end, not as bad as ANTEGATE but bad enough (5:40 onwards This evening I will be playing the role of Lisandro)

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Buqjfvh86HU
  • edited May 2011
    you called him so he has to show his cards
    Thats the whole point of calling, you call to see there cards so they must turn first.
    If he refuses then you refuse, call the TD over he can make a ruling.
    The dealer should not deal the river if your not happy.

    To claim a pot you must show both cards.

    I would have stuck that card he threw at you in his mouth but hey ho
  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:
    Am not 100% on this.  Pretty sure if bet is matched its showdown time regardless of street in T   Have definitely played cash games where money went in pre, but cards were only shown when full hand was dealt out. Might be different in tourneys, and it might be something thats different in different casinos
    Posted by grantorino
    Yeah cash live is sometimes like that where you only have to show to claim the pot

    Because houses have variations on the rules if you are in any doubt then just ask for the TD to be called over
    DON'T BE SHY IT'S YOUR MONEY
  • edited May 2011
    Like I said I wasnt asking for clarification on the ruling, I know the ruling! lol.

    Was asking peoples opinions on the etiquette. being his (maybe I should have made it clearer) + how they'd react to it. Mainly as I felt a bit bad for getting in his face, but your last comment sums it up nicely :)

    There would have been no more action at the table until I saw his second card, fullstop.  Not happening.
  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:
    Like I said I wasnt asking for clarification on the ruling, I know the ruling! lol. Was asking peoples opinions on the etiquette. being his (maybe I should have made it clearer) + how they'd react to it. Mainly as I felt a bit bad for getting in his face, but your last comment sums it up nicely :) There would have been no more action at the table until I saw his second card, fullstop.  Not happening.
    Posted by AMYBR
    I would of complained to the TD, try and get this player sat out, put him on tilt and take all his angry chips :D
    Simples
  • edited May 2011
    I just saw red when he threw card at me, never happened to me before.  Him hitting the K on river when money was in at turn likely didnt help either :)

    It happened as soon as  I said no action bring TD over.  Then by time TD got there I was pretty aggro.  Not really like me but I'd have only sat there and steamed if hadnt have let him no how out of order it was. 

    Some people are just plonkers.
  • edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: Live Etiquette check/How do you react?:
    I just saw red when he threw card at me, never happened to me before.  Him hitting the K on river when money was in at turn likely didnt help either :) It happened as soon as  I said no action bring TD over.  Then by time TD got there I was pretty aggro.  Not really like me but I'd have only sat there and steamed if hadnt have let him no how out of order it was.  Some people are just plonkers.
    Posted by AMYBR
    Hi AMYBR,

    Live poker sounds like fun!

    Took Mrs Z out for a meal saturday night then we popped into a Gala casino for a couple of hours and to watch the end of the Barcelona game, but I kept hovering around the poker tables, it was full ring 25/50 with a max £100 buy-in, but every pot had at least half a dozen limpers!!!

    I was gagging to sit down but just didnt have the confidence.

    Must have a go soon though.
Sign In or Register to comment.