Simple as was this good shove or not?

iBLUFF

This was my exit hand of the TOT, a couple said it was the right shove, which is what i belive but also a couple said it was a bad shove . so now i come to you the people of the poker clinic was this a good shove or not? tyty

Player	Action	Cards	Amount	Pot	Balance
iBLUFF	Small blind		800.00	800.00	15698.75
Mac247	Big blind		1600.00	2400.00	56001.25
	Your hole cards	A 2
wynne1938	Fold
GEO68	Fold
MyZo	Fold
iBLUFF	All-in		15698.75	18098.75	0.00
Mac247	Call		14898.75	32997.50	41102.50
iBLUFF	Show	A 2
Mac247	Show	Q J
Flop
		4 4 J
Turn
		K
River
		J
Mac247	Win	Full House, Jacks and 4s	32997.50		74100.00

percival09

Shoving is the right play here imo. 

YOUNG_GUN

I like it, UL SIR

waller02

yep standard shove, got it in ahead and ul

GREGHOGG

as much as i hate raggy aces...

its fine

jakally

Blind on Blind with 10 bigs is a shove with any two against most players..... you would have to be called around 30% of the time to make it breakeven / unprofitable.

Against tightish players shove any two. against players calling wider just lop off the bottom 20 - 30% of hands.

Obv. adjust a bit for prizepool factors.... money bubble, next pay jump is significant and there are shorter stacks etc....

Dudeskin8

You got a call you wanted, what's your problem?

AMYBR

Souldnt be folding, shouldnt be making up the 800.  Dont like making it 3200 - 4500.

Jam is fine, his call is really bad for half his stack with Q high

iBLUFF

In Response to Re: Simple as was this good shove or not?:

You got a call you wanted, what's your problem?
Posted by Dudeskin8

I have no problem mate, just that it was mixed opinions in the chat as to if it was a good shove or not so thought i would ask it here.

DOHHHHHHH

This hand should be at the top end of your shoving range here.

As Jakally has already said, pretty much any 2.

I would fold total garbage sometimes, as I'm on the button next hand and I can maybe find a slightly better spot than shoving stuff like 62o here.

Folding Ax wud be sooooooooooo bad though.

wp, ul.

grantorino

standard shove dont mind fish in the chatbox

silentbob

FWIW I'm shoving any ace here & I'm not very good

iBLUFF

Thanks all, i thought my shove was right just had to make sure.

P.S i asked the player in chat "if i won the hand would you still of thought it was a bad shove" he didnt reply...

corn_rat22

Right play in the long run, UL

Codex

shove is correct but i disagree with the critiscism of the call precisely because he could be shoving with any 2 and QJ is comfortably above average

iBLUFF

In Response to Re: Simple as was this good shove or not?:

shove is correct but i disagree with the critiscism of the call precisely because he could be shoving with any 2 and QJ is comfortably above average
Posted by Codex

Personaly i didnt say anything about his call, i think with how i was playing he has to snap call there.