You need to be logged in to your Sky Poker account above to post discussions and comments.

You might need to refresh your page afterwards.

Sky Poker forums will be temporarily unavailable from 11pm Wednesday July 25th.
Sky Poker Forums is upgrading its look! Stay tuned for the big reveal!

Some Advice would be appreciated

edited January 2010 in Poker Chat

Would be grateful if someone could tell me why I got dogs abuse for this hand earlier this evening....

PlayerActionCardsAmountPotBalance
festa01 Small blind  50.00 50.00 3165.00
leegibbo Big blind  100.00 150.00 3840.00
  Your hole cards
  • K
  • 3
     
barrie1979 Call  100.00 250.00 2720.00
(toiletmouth)All-in  1440.00 1690.00 0.00
emilyegg Call  1440.00 3130.00 5145.00
festa01 Fold     
leegibbo Fold     
barrie1979 Call  1340.00 4470.00 1380.00
Flop
   
  • J
  • Q
  • 9
     
barrie1979 Check     
emilyegg Check     
Turn
   
  • A
     
barrie1979 Check     
emilyegg Check     
River
   
  • 7
     
barrie1979 Check     
emilyegg Bet  100.00 4570.00 5045.00
barrie1979 Call  100.00 4670.00 1280.00
(toiletmouth) Show
  • J
  • Q
   
emilyegg Show
  • K
  • 3
   
barrie1979 Muck
  • 6
  • A
   
emilyegg Win Flush to the King 4670.00  9715.00
I am a regular player on small stake STT and MTT games.

In this one table game I was leading and called the short stack when he went all in.

The player I knocked out of the game was not a tight player by any means and I dont think my call against the short stack was Fishy or Bingo`ish.

Abuse.....I can cope with it if it is warranted, but I would genuinely like to know if (without hindsight) I made the right call, or was I lucky?
«1

Comments

  • edited January 2010


    To be honest you should not be calling all ins for more than 10 big blinds with K3. you may say you were ahead but you cannot and should not think that this is the case. It's a rubbish hand. I don't know what the A6 is doing calling either. I can only assume that this is some kind of 50p SNG where people are having a bit of fun.
  • edited January 2010

    Personally in this instance I wouldn't have called a 14x shove with that junk, but each to their own :) Don't like the later call either (A6)

  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    To be honest you should not be calling all ins for more than 10 big blinds with K3. you may say you were ahead but you cannot and should not think that this is the case. It's a rubbish hand. I don't know what the A6 is doing calling either. I can only assume that this is some kind of 50p SNG were people are having a bit of fun.
    Posted by salazar
    Thanks for that m8.
  • edited January 2010
    Hey Em,

    As far as I see it, you knew this guy was a loose player, you had position and was chip leader...if you wanted to take the gamble (which you did) you should not be berated for it...

    This person sounds like they were having a bad night and were possibly on tilt...if you can, put it behind you but make sure you avoid the player in future, if it still upsets you report to customer services who will investigate on your behalf...

    hope this helps, and good luck in your other games tonight x

  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    Personally in this instance I wouldn't have called a 14x shove with that junk, but each to their own :) Don't like the later call either (A6)
    Posted by NoseyBonk
    Again, Thanks for response. Advice from experienced players is great.

    Can I throw in another Question?.........

    What would be the best way to play against a player who was betting/raising with hole cards not as good as the ones he had when he went out.
    I appreciate that being patient is good advice, but when you do get premium hole cards.....will players shove anyway?
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    Hey Em, As far as I see it, you knew this guy was a loose player, you had position and was chip leader...if you wanted to take the gamble (which you did) you should not be berated for it... This person sounds like they were having a bad night and were possibly on tilt...if you can, put it behind you but make sure you avoid the player in future, if it still upsets you report to customer services who will investigate on your behalf... hope this helps, and good luck in your other games tonight x
    Posted by TRIP5
    Thanks TRIP5 X
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : Thanks for that m8.
    Posted by emilyegg
    No problem, the bottom line is it's your money, play how you want to . Me, I would fold a hand like that but there is no need for people to abuse you for not folding, like I said, it's your money, your chips, you should play how you want to and not how somebody else thinks you should.
    If you want advice, there are plenty of people on here that will offer you that advice.

    Salazar
  • ybyb
    edited January 2010
    Fwiw I hate your call here. To call an all-in for 14bb's with K-3 is just so bad in the long run, even if he has been a bit loose. Also I don't get why you're only betting 100 chips on the end into a pot of 4470 with the 2nd nuts.
  • edited January 2010
    lol thats class... you got berated because you made a poor call preflop, and then made a poor value bet on the river...
    so advice... well why did you call that preflop? and why only bet 100 on the river with the 2nd nuts?
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    Fwiw I hate your call here. To call an all-in for 14bb's with K-3 is just so bad in the long run, even if he has been a bit loose. Also I don't get why you're only betting 100 chips on the end into a pot of 4470 with the 2nd nuts.
    Posted by yb
    Again, many thanks. Only threw in the minimum bet at the end to try and encourage a raise.
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    lol thats class... you got berated because you made a poor call preflop, and then made a poor value bet on the river... so advice... well why did you call that preflop? and why only bet 100 on the river with the 2nd nuts?
    Posted by BlackFish3
    jeez
  • ybyb
    edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : Again, many thanks. Only threw in the minimum bet at the end to try and encourage a raise.
    Posted by emilyegg
    Once you've seen him check twice I don't think you can expect him to do the betting for you. And with a player already all-in there's no way he'd re-raise you on the river unless he had a really big hand. Basically you should have just put him all-in and with so much in the pot already he'd probably call with any half decent hand.
  • edited January 2010
    hi emilyegg m8.nothing wrong with your call at all at this level,reason being that at this level you and i know they bet with anything.your mate dav
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : Once you've seen him check twice I don't think you can expect him to do the betting for you. And with a player already all-in there's no way he'd re-raise you on the river unless he had a really big hand. Basically you should have just put him all-in and with so much in the pot already he'd probably call with any half decent hand.
    Posted by yb
    Thanks yb, I have learnt a lot from the replies I have had since I posted. It does make sense and is greatly appreciated. I am fairly new to these threads and take great interest in reading them.

    I am greatly encouraged by the helpful response I have had from everyone thus far (except Jeez man, who must be the youngest WSOP bracelet holder in Poker History) ;.)
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    hi emilyegg m8.nothing wrong with your call at all at this level,reason being that at this level you and i know they bet with anything.your mate dav
    Posted by dav1964
    Cheers Dav.
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Some Advice would be appreciated:
    Would be grateful if someone could tell me why I got dogs abuse for this hand earlier this evening.... Player Action Cards Amount Pot Balance festa01 Small blind   50.00 50.00 3165.00 leegibbo Big blind   100.00 150.00 3840.00   Your hole cards K 3       barrie1979 Call   100.00 250.00 2720.00 (toiletmouth) All-in   1440.00 1690.00 0.00 emilyegg Call   1440.00 3130.00 5145.00 festa01 Fold         leegibbo Fold         barrie1979 Call   1340.00 4470.00 1380.00 Flop     J Q 9       barrie1979 Check         emilyegg Check         Turn     A       barrie1979 Check         emilyegg Check         River     7       barrie1979 Check         emilyegg Bet   100.00 4570.00 5045.00 barrie1979 Call   100.00 4670.00 1280.00 (toiletmouth)  Show J Q       emilyegg Show K 3       barrie1979 Muck 6 A       emilyegg Win Flush to the King 4670.00   9715.00 I am a regular player on small stake STT and MTT games. In this one table game I was leading and called the short stack when he went all in. The player I knocked out of the game was not a tight player by any means and I dont think my call against the short stack was Fishy or Bingo`ish. Abuse.....I can cope with it if it is warranted, but I would genuinely like to know if (without hindsight) I made the right call, or was I lucky?
    Posted by emilyegg

    you got the abuse for one reason.....you won the hand,if you had lost the player would of punched the air in delight..imo it was a loose call but then i wasnt on the table and had'nt seen previous actions....good luck, dave..



    ps you dont/should'nt have to "cope" with abuse,if its bad report it
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Some Advice would be appreciated : you got the abuse for one reason.....you won the hand,if you had lost the player would of punched the air in delight..imo it was a loose call but then i wasnt on the table and had'nt seen previous actions....good luck, dave.. ps you dont/should'nt have to "cope" with abuse,if its bad report it
    Posted by DAVEYZZ
    That sums it up perfectly.
    The "ps" is particularly important.
  • edited January 2010
    Many Thanks DAVEYZZ & MereNovice.
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : That sums it up perfectly. The "ps" is particularly important.
    Posted by MereNovice
    Out of interest though MereNovice.....I only ask this because I have read a lot of your posts and know that you are very knowledgable, (especially on odds etc).......Against this player who was calling and raising with almost anything, what odds would you put K3 suited against him if they were your cards?.... when he is short stacked.
    Thanks.
  • edited January 2010
    It's very sweet of you to say that!   :-)

    The problem with K3 (even if sooooooted) is that it doesn't play well against just about any hand that your opponent is likely to have and plays terribly against others. Calling with it is definitely bad and certainly for that amount of chips.

    Here are the odds against some of the hands that your opponent might have had:

    QsJc      58/42
    KcQs     30/70
    Ac4c      37/63
    8c8s      33/67

    The first figure is your percentage chance against an opponent with the stated hand (the second figure is your opponent's percentage). Your opponent had 14bb which isn't really short-stacked in most of the games played on this site. As you can see you were very lucky (or a VERY good judge of your opponent!) to be ahead.

    There is a tool called PokerStove that you can download for free that allows you to judge the strength of your hand against a whole range of your opponent's hands. If you want to look more into the odds of certain hands, I thoroughly recommend this tool.

    Having said that, the hands and odds are irrelevant in this case. Abuse is unacceptable and should not be tolerated.
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    It's very sweet of you to say that!   :-) The problem with K3 (even if sooooooted) is that it doesn't play well against just about any hand that your opponent is likely to have and plays terribly against others. Calling with it is definitely bad and certainly for that amount of chips. Here are the odds against some of the hands that your opponent might have had: QsJc      58/42 KcQs     30/70 Ac4c      37/63 8c8s      33/67 The first figure is your percentage chance against an opponent with the stated hand (the second figure is your opponent's percentage). Your opponent had 14bb which isn't really short-stacked in most of the games played on this site. As you can see you were very lucky (or a VERY good judge of your opponent!) to be ahead. There is a tool called PokerStove that you can download for free that allows you to judge the strength of your hand against a whole range of your opponent's hands. If you want to look more into the odds of certain hands, I thoroughly recommend this tool. Having said that, the hands and odds are irrelevant in this case. Abuse is unacceptable and should not be tolerated.
    Posted by MereNovice
    Very Interesting Reading and Thanks Again MereNovice, really pleased I posted this thread now. Lots of good advice and obvious errors pointed out in a positive and polite way from all but one.......(jeeez) shocked gasps!!!
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Some Advice would be appreciated : you got the abuse for one reason.....you won the hand,if you had lost the player would of punched the air in delight..imo it was a loose call but then i wasnt on the table and had'nt seen previous actions....good luck, dave.. ps you dont/should'nt have to "cope" with abuse,if its bad report it
    Posted by DAVEYZZ
    As simple as that.
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : As simple as that.
    Posted by Tikay10
    Thank You TK. You taking the time to read and post is appreciated greatly.
  • edited January 2010
    emily at this level of poker anything goes because it is likely only recreational, so have fun and call with K 3 suited if thats what you wanna do.
    Ironically ur the one on here asking questions and looking to improve so all credit to you... whoever was 'berating' you is probly never gonna get better so dont let that abuse get to u, just be happy and content that you have learnt from the hand and move on. GL
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : Thanks yb, I have learnt a lot from the replies I have had since I posted. It does make sense and is greatly appreciated. I am fairly new to these threads and take great interest in reading them. I am greatly encouraged by the helpful response I have had from everyone thus far (except Jeez man, who must be the youngest WSOP bracelet holder in Poker History) ;.)
    Posted by emilyegg
    ok clearly dont want any advice that tells you that you didnt play the hand well... why bother asking if you are going to make comments like this? i may be young but that is no reason to discard my advice because i am not a bad player.
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : ok clearly don't want any advice that tells you that you didn't play the hand well... why bother asking if you are going to make comments like this? i may be young but that is no reason to discard my advice because i am not a bad player.
    Posted by BlackFish3
    Missing the point a wee bit Blackfish.......

    Are You a good player? I don`t honestly know m8.

    Have I received good advice on this thread and taken it on board? Yes

    If you actually take the time to read the posters who have offered advice to me you will see that it is done in a constructive, non-patronising way.

    From yourself, I get a "lol......thats class".

    I don't know if its the way you come across m8, (and like I said earlier I am fairly new to these threads) but I have noticed that 99% of your posts are very negative and almost condescending towards people and the way they play. (jeez)
    Far better players than me have made points/views on threads, but sadly (imo) you still have a tendency to shoot people down and be a bit barbed in your replies.
    To me it looks like you enjoy being a bit confrontational and while it is clear that you possess a sound knowledge of Poker, I am almost certain that If you were made from Chocolate you would eat yourself.

    Anyway, Thanks for your input and Good Luck "Top Gun"
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : Missing the point a wee bit Blackfish....... Are You a good player? I don`t honestly know m8. Have I received good advice on this thread and taken it on board? Yes If you actually take the time to read the posters who have offered advice to me you will see that it is done in a constructive, non-patronising way. From yourself, I get a "lol......thats class". I don't know if its the way you come across m8, (and like I said earlier I am fairly new to these threads) but I have noticed that 99% of your posts are very negative and almost condescending towards people and the way they play. (jeez) Far better players than me have made points/views on threads, but sadly (imo) you still have a tendency to shoot people down and be a bit barbed in your replies. To me it looks like you enjoy being a bit confrontational and while it is clear that you possess a sound knowledge of Poker, I am almost certain that If you were made from Chocolate you would eat yourself. Anyway, Thanks for your input and Good Luck "Top Gun"
    Posted by emilyegg
    hi again mate.my advice?take all of the constructive advice you have been given and dont rise to any bait on any catty remarks or sarcasm.all the best dav
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : Missing the point a wee bit Blackfish....... Are You a good player? I don`t honestly know m8. Have I received good advice on this thread and taken it on board? Yes If you actually take the time to read the posters who have offered advice to me you will see that it is done in a constructive, non-patronising way. From yourself, I get a "lol......thats class". I don't know if its the way you come across m8, (and like I said earlier I am fairly new to these threads) but I have noticed that 99% of your posts are very negative and almost condescending towards people and the way they play. (jeez) Far better players than me have made points/views on threads, but sadly (imo) you still have a tendency to shoot people down and be a bit barbed in your replies. To me it looks like you enjoy being a bit confrontational and while it is clear that you possess a sound knowledge of Poker, I am almost certain that If you were made from Chocolate you would eat yourself. Anyway, Thanks for your input and Good Luck "Top Gun"
    Posted by emilyegg
    ahhh i guess your right. My intention is to give help to players but maybe i dont project myself in the best way whilst doing so. i do enjoy an argument (im a law student what do you expect lol?) but i dont intend to cause any... and if i was made of chocolate... yea id eat myself lol... actually maybe i wouldnt because then there wudnt be any more of me left and that would be terrible!

    Ok now for some 'friendly' advice... the 10BB call with the K3s is poor because you are unlikely to be ahead of the player who has gone all in. Also by calling you get other players calling such as the A6... if you want to play this hand then consider reraising in order to isolate the original shover. On the river you min bet... you have the 2nd nuts and so want to extract maxium value and in order to do this you must bet more... an example:
    say you bet 600 and 1 out of 5 times he calls... therefore you make 600 chips 1 in 5 times... now if you bet 100 and he calls every time then you only make 500 chips.
    in the words of the great man himself...
    hope this helps
  • edited January 2010
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated:
    In Response to Re: Some Advice would be appreciated : ahhh i guess your right. My intention is to give help to players but maybe i dont project myself in the best way whilst doing so. i do enjoy an argument (im a law student what do you expect lol?) but i dont intend to cause any... and if i was made of chocolate... yea id eat myself lol... actually maybe i wouldnt because then there wudnt be any more of me left and that would be terrible! Ok now for some 'friendly' advice... the 10BB call with the K3s is poor because you are unlikely to be ahead of the player who has gone all in. Also by calling you get other players calling such as the A6... if you want to play this hand then consider reraising in order to isolate the original shover. On the river you min bet... you have the 2nd nuts and so want to extract maxium value and in order to do this you must bet more... an example: say you bet 600 and 1 out of 5 times he calls... therefore you make 600 chips 1 in 5 times... now if you bet 100 and he calls every time then you only make 500 chips. in the words of the great man himself... hope this helps
    Posted by BlackFish3
    Apologies to you BlackFish, my earlier post was out of order. I can be a bit sarcastic at times.

    Gutted that I missed the link between you being a Law Student and enjoying an argument though!

    In all seriousness though your advice (and everyone else who has been kind enough to give input and pointers) has been greatly appreciated....Apologies again if it sounded like I was rude to you. Although I have barely played since I started this thread last night, I feel that I am now a wiser player thanks to Everybodys posts, and will look at certain situations in a different way from now on.

    I can honestly say I have came to a few conclusions since I wandered onto these threads by accident just before xmas.

    The threads are a good source of Joy/Pain/Laughter/Tears/Odd People/Good People/Conspiracy Theories, et cetera.

    Without seeing many Players "in action" it is obvious that there are some very knowledgable and superb players out there, (yourself included) just by reading the posts on these threads.

    I only play at small stake/bingo level where it seems at times that everyone would call a deaf dog. I can hang my head and say I have done this myself before, (see start of thread lol) but If I get enough time I might have a read at a few books/sites to try and become a better player and even enjoy Poker more than I do now.

    Respect and Apologies again to you BlackFish. And Good Luck.
  • edited January 2010
    I think you have had some excellent advice on here Emily, and you seem to be quite happy to accept the "Constructive" critisisum that has been posted.

    At the end of the day, any player can fold, call or raise, with any two cards from any position.  Why?  Because they want to.  

    Accept that this is a part of playing poker, or go take up another game.  Your opponent, obviously, was incapable of taking this little known poker fact on board

    Keep winning 
Sign In or Register to comment.