As the Community/Forum gets bigger & bigger, there have to be seperate Boards for varying topics, or the whole thing just becomes a complete nonsense, & it would be impossible to locate particular Threads or topics.
Moving it to "The Shed" is not a slur on the Thread, not one bit, it just belongs in The Shed, no more, no less.
If that Thread were to stay in GPC, then everyone else, who normally Post stuff in The Shed, would want their threads on GPC.
And if that happened, why not just close "The Shed", & all the other Boards? Stick everything in GPC. Which would soon collapse under the load, as Threads would "fall off" the Front Page so much quicker.
It's just sensible Forum husbandry, & in NO WAY reflects upon the quality, or otherwise, of the Thread.
I stick to GPC most of the time, others only visit "The Shed", it's each to their own. Jack Spratt & his missus, sort of thing.
If anyone can Post any thread anywhere, the whole Forum will collapse into disarray. There have to be & are, exceptions, but I think they have to be just that - rare exceptions.
To repeat, the decision to move it is standard Forum husbandry, & does not, in any way, reflect upon the Thread.
Guys. As the Community/Forum gets bigger & bigger, there have to be seperate Boards for varying topics, or the whole thing just becomes a complete nonsense, & it would be impossible to locate particular Threads or topics. Moving it to "The Shed" is not a slur on the Thread, not one bit, it just belongs in The Shed, no more, no less. If that Thread were to stay in GPC, then everyone else, who normally Post stuff in The Shed, would want their threads on GPC. And if that happened, why not just close "The Shed", & all the other Boards? Stick everything in GPC. Which would soon collapse under the load, as Threads would "fall off" the Front Page so much quicker. It's just sensible Forum husbandry, & in NO WAY reflects upon the quality, or otherwise, of the Thread. I stick to GPC most of the time, others only visit "The Shed", it's each to their own. Jack Spratt & his missus, sort of thing. If anyone can Post any thread anywhere, the whole Forum will collapse into disarray. There have to be & are, exceptions, but I think they have to be just that - rare exceptions. To repeat, the decision to move it is standard Forum husbandry, & does not, in any way, reflect upon the Thread. Posted by Tikay10
Imo This thread was about the players which are the most important part of the game without them you dont have a game! It is not as though it was about cats in bins or footy!
fair point tikay but why wasnt it moved when irishrover did this last time?? Posted by donkeyplop
No idea, Mr Plop, but how do two wrongs make a right?
Sorry to sound obdurate, but the relevance of why it was allowed to remain on the wrong board last time is lost on me.
In addition, Forum Traffic (number of Posts per week) is increasing week-on-week, & has been for a while now, with the rate now accelerating, so it's far more of a problem now than it was previously.
I also expect Forum Traffic here to significantly improve even further very soon, as there are a whole bunch of exciting, & very special, things, soon to "go public", which will, collectively, create a lot more Posts.
""I stick to GPC most of the time, others only visit "The Shed", it's each to their own.''
With all due respect, this is one of the reasons where I feel it would be beneficial to the 'whole' community if this thread was in GPC. There are too many 'negative' theme threads appearing in GPC ATM and this would hopefully readdress the balance. (IMHO)
If the 'vegas' threads were in the 'tournament' thread and not the GPC.......would they of got the amount of response they did?.
Its too early for a normal Friday forum fight, so I will just say the above because I know it will be pointless in pursuing the 'discussion'.
In Response to Re: petition to return irishrovers forum bb thread!!!! : No idea, Mr Plop, but how do two wrongs make a right? Sorry to sound obdurate, but the relevance of why it was allowed to remain on the wrong board last time is lost on me. In addition, Forum Traffic (number of Posts per week) is increasing week-on-week, & has been for a while now, with the rate now accelerating, so it's far more of a problem now than it was previously. I also expect Forum Traffic here to significantly improve even further very soon, as there are a whole bunch of exciting, & very special, things, soon to "go public", which will, collectively, create a lot more Posts. Posted by Tikay10
Within your typically well worded reply TK you mention you very rarely go to the shed.
Same with me, I very rarely get past the main Poker Chat forum and hardly ever visit the Shed in particular.
That's why I'm adding my name to this petition
I think this particular thread deserves to be on the main forum .....giving it a "Coronation Street" or "X Factor" status if you like.
By moving it to the Shed only the die hard forum regs will remember to visit it; and that would be a great shame. This is a chance for some cracking fun ....and to show the community at its best.
I therefore still respectfully vote/suggest to......Move it back.
Guys. As the Community/Forum gets bigger & bigger, there have to be seperate Boards for varying topics, or the whole thing just becomes a complete nonsense, & it would be impossible to locate particular Threads or topics. Moving it to "The Shed" is not a slur on the Thread, not one bit, it just belongs in The Shed, no more, no less. If that Thread were to stay in GPC, then everyone else, who normally Post stuff in The Shed, would want their threads on GPC. And if that happened, why not just close "The Shed", & all the other Boards? Stick everything in GPC. Which would soon collapse under the load, as Threads would "fall off" the Front Page so much quicker. It's just sensible Forum husbandry, & in NO WAY reflects upon the quality, or otherwise, of the Thread. I stick to GPC most of the time, others only visit "The Shed", it's each to their own. Jack Spratt & his missus, sort of thing. If anyone can Post any thread anywhere, the whole Forum will collapse into disarray. There have to be & are, exceptions, but I think they have to be just that - rare exceptions. To repeat, the decision to move it is standard Forum husbandry, & does not, in any way, reflect upon the Thread. Posted by Tikay10
you know i think you are a topman tk and so is skyrich ,
but why cant this be a rare exception ?
a lot of forum peeps want it ,
its harmless fun just what is needed ,
positive harmless fun ,
this thread would have worked better in general chat !
In addition, Forum Traffic (number of Posts per week) is increasing week-on-week, & has been for a while now, with the rate now accelerating, so it's far more of a problem now than it was previously.Posted by Tikay10
Tikay! I know this is an impertinent question but did you even look at the said thread before giving your judgement on the situation? If you did then I respect your judgment even though Imo I think you are wrong!
Ok folks I'm going to move it back into here in a moment. Given the bad vibes that have been circulating here recently I think it's a good idea, as it's a good fun thread.
This doesn't mean you can start a petition whenever a thread gets moved in future ;-) It's a one off for today only.
Ok folks I'm going to move it back into here in a moment. Given the bad vibes that have been circulating here recently I think it's a good idea, as it's a good fun thread. This doesn't mean you can start a petition whenever a thread gets moved in future ;-) It's a one off for today only. Moderator. Posted by Sky_mod3
Ok folks I'm going to move it back into here in a moment. Given the bad vibes that have been circulating here recently I think it's a good idea, as it's a good fun thread. This doesn't mean you can start a petition whenever a thread gets moved in future ;-) It's a one off for today only. Moderator. Posted by Sky_mod3
In Response to Re: petition to return irishrovers forum bb thread!!!! : you know i think you are a topman tk and so is skyrich , but why cant this be a rare exception ? a lot of forum peeps want it , its harmless fun just what is needed , positive harmless fun , this thread would have worked better in general chat ! Posted by IRISHROVER
I almost wished I never made my Post, now I definitely wish I'd never made it. I was worried people would not read it properly, & that has proven to be the case.
I never said it could not be a rare exception, I simply went to the time & trouble to explain the logic.
I never said (or thought) that a lot of people did or did not want it.
I never said (or thought) it was not harmless fun.
What I did explain was how Forums need to work, & be managed, if they are to be scaleable, to be able to survive traffic growth.
Now we have "mock" Posts appearing on other Threads.
I'm really sorry you never read my Post properly, nevertheless.
""I stick to GPC most of the time, others only visit "The Shed", it's each to their own.'' With all due respect, this is one of the reasons where I feel it would be beneficial to the 'whole' community if this thread was in GPC. There are too many 'negative' theme threads appearing in GPC ATM and this would hopefully readdress the balance. (IMHO) If the 'vegas' threads were in the 'tournament' thread and not the GPC.......would they of got the amount of response they did?. Its too early for a normal Friday forum fight, so I will just say the above because I know it will be pointless in pursuing the 'discussion'. ' LONG LIVE DAVINNA ' Posted by MAXALLY
Comments
irishrover
the last forum bb thread went on for ages and was never moved!!!!
there must be a grumpy forum mod lurking lol.
Yeah they seem to be in a bit of a mood today,cant really think why though.I guess some fool musta peed em off ;o)
Guys.
As the Community/Forum gets bigger & bigger, there have to be seperate Boards for varying topics, or the whole thing just becomes a complete nonsense, & it would be impossible to locate particular Threads or topics.
Moving it to "The Shed" is not a slur on the Thread, not one bit, it just belongs in The Shed, no more, no less.
If that Thread were to stay in GPC, then everyone else, who normally Post stuff in The Shed, would want their threads on GPC.
And if that happened, why not just close "The Shed", & all the other Boards? Stick everything in GPC. Which would soon collapse under the load, as Threads would "fall off" the Front Page so much quicker.
It's just sensible Forum husbandry, & in NO WAY reflects upon the quality, or otherwise, of the Thread.
I stick to GPC most of the time, others only visit "The Shed", it's each to their own. Jack Spratt & his missus, sort of thing.
If anyone can Post any thread anywhere, the whole Forum will collapse into disarray. There have to be & are, exceptions, but I think they have to be just that - rare exceptions.
To repeat, the decision to move it is standard Forum husbandry, & does not, in any way, reflect upon the Thread.
also i didnt get a vote so dont care lol
Sorry to sound obdurate, but the relevance of why it was allowed to remain on the wrong board last time is lost on me.
In addition, Forum Traffic (number of Posts per week) is increasing week-on-week, & has been for a while now, with the rate now accelerating, so it's far more of a problem now than it was previously.
I also expect Forum Traffic here to significantly improve even further very soon, as there are a whole bunch of exciting, & very special, things, soon to "go public", which will, collectively, create a lot more Posts.
Same with me, I very rarely get past the main Poker Chat forum and hardly ever visit the Shed in particular.
That's why I'm adding my name to this petition
I think this particular thread deserves to be on the main forum .....giving it a "Coronation Street" or "X Factor" status if you like.
By moving it to the Shed only the die hard forum regs will remember to visit it; and that would be a great shame. This is a chance for some cracking fun ....and to show the community at its best.
I therefore still respectfully vote/suggest to......Move it back.
Dud Butini.
but why cant this be a rare exception ?
a lot of forum peeps want it ,
its harmless fun just what is needed ,
positive harmless fun ,
this thread would have worked better in general chat !
This doesn't mean you can start a petition whenever a thread gets moved in future ;-) It's a one off for today only.
Moderator.
n1 this is why skypoker is tops !
I never said it could not be a rare exception, I simply went to the time & trouble to explain the logic.
I never said (or thought) that a lot of people did or did not want it.
I never said (or thought) it was not harmless fun.
What I did explain was how Forums need to work, & be managed, if they are to be scaleable, to be able to survive traffic growth.
Now we have "mock" Posts appearing on other Threads.
I'm really sorry you never read my Post properly, nevertheless.
BOOM !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!